From Seances to Science: A Look at Early Spiritualist Beliefs
Have you ever wondered if communication with the departed is possible? This age-old question lies at the heart of spiritualism, a belief system that has captivated humanity for centuries.
From the fame of the Fox sisters in the 19th century to the rise of modern ghost hunting, spiritualism continues to influence our perception of the afterlife and the otherworldly. But what is the truth behind this practice?
In this two-part blog series, US Ghost Adventures embarks on a thrilling investigation into the world of spiritualism. Prepare for a deep dive into its history, explore its evolution in the modern age, and examine the scientific and skeptical perspectives surrounding it.
What is Spiritualism?
Have you ever wondered if it’s possible to talk to the dead? This belief in contacting the spirits of the dead falls under the umbrella term “spiritualism.”
Britannica defines spiritualism as “a movement based on the belief that departed souls can interact with the living.” This concept applies to those who believe they can communicate with the dead, either directly or by acting as a vessel for spirits to speak with loved ones or even manipulate the physical world.
Spiritualism isn’t limited to historical practices. Many modern Americans might be familiar with tools associated with it, like the Ouija board. Today’s “ghost hunting” enthusiasts often utilize equipment like night vision goggles and cameras, believing these tools help them interact with or “connect” with the spirits of the deceased. This is also linked to early ideas of spiritualism.
The Early Beginnings of Spiritualism
The belief in contacting the dead has a long and global reach. For centuries, cultures worldwide have developed practices to connect with the deceased. Ancient Egyptians, for example, buried their dead with favorite possessions, believing they could still enjoy them in the afterlife. Egyptians also wrote “Letters to the Dead” at tombs, seeking protection or guidance from those who had passed.
Even today, traditions like the Dogon people’s masquerade dances in Mali serve as a bridge between the living and the dead. These practices are likely not isolated, suggesting spiritualism remains a cultural custom in many corners of the world. However, the history of spiritualism isn’t always positive. In the Middle Ages, mediums were often demonized.
Their ability to communicate with the deceased was seen as witchcraft and satanic, not divinely inspired. This fear of the “otherworldly” repeated itself during the witch trials of colonial America, where women with unexplained abilities faced persecution and death.
The Fox Sisters Shake Up Spiritualism
The Fox sisters are undeniably linked to the rise of modern spiritualism. Their story begins in March 1848, when teenagers Maggie and Kate Fox claimed a spirit in their New York home communicated with them through raps and knocks on the walls and furniture. The girls deciphered these messages, believing them to be from a murdered man. A neighbor backed up the story, and the Fox home became a center of curiosity and scrutiny.
Soon after, the sisters moved in with their older sister, Leah, who capitalized on their supposed “talents” and turned them into a lucrative business. Maggie and Kate held seances for paying audiences, attracting media attention, and performing for large crowds in New York City.
While some suspected the girls were simply cracking their knuckles and other joints (a confession Maggie made in 1888), the public largely believed in their abilities, and this propelled them to stardom. Soon, the sisters’ success inspired others. In the 1850s, Ira and William Davenport emerged with a magic show supposedly fueled by “supernatural” feats.
This rise in spiritualist performances also gave rise to a new breed of celebrity: magicians who debunked them. For example, the famous Harry Houdini was passionate about exposing the tricks behind these spiritualist magic shows and, after becoming well-known in his own right, worked to dispel the claims of the Foxes, Davenports, and others. Despite these efforts, spiritualism remained popular.
The Fox sisters’ story came to an interesting conclusion in 1888 when Maggie confessed that the raps were a hoax, achieved by the sisters cracking their toes and using other techniques. This confession tarnished the credibility of the spiritualist movement, but it didn’t completely eliminate it. The desire to connect with loved ones who had passed on – particularly during the Civil War, when so many suffered loss and grief – kept the fires of spiritualism burning bright.
What Attracted People to Spiritualism?
Despite skepticism surrounding spiritualism, the practice drew many people to it. Some people simply found it entertaining and fun to think about. For others, spiritualism offered comfort, the chance to connect with loved ones who had passed.
Mary Todd Lincoln, wife of Abraham Lincoln, exemplifies this belief. A firm spiritualist, she held seances in the White House to communicate with her deceased sons. Similarly, Queen Victoria, following the death of her husband Prince Albert in 1861, held many seances in Buckingham Palace to connect with him.
Interestingly, the Fox sisters’ confession didn’t turn away all believers. It seems the perceived benefits of spiritualism and the comfort it offered outweighed the fact that it was probably all fake.
It’s easy to see why holding seances and engaging in related activities remained a popular pastime for many Victorian-era people. The 19th century witnessed an incredible amount of social and technological change. Traditional religious beliefs began to fade, and certain world events, like the Civil War, revealed a darker underbelly of the American dream. Spiritualism offered an alternative way to grapple with mortality, the unknown, and the nature of existence, which was a great comfort.
Spiritualism Comes Under Attack
Similar to the Middle Ages, Christianity in the 19th century clashed with spiritualism. Church leaders condemned the practice, associating it with witchcraft and Satanism. Some even faced violence from hostile mobs. This disapproval stemmed from the belief that spiritualists were practicing necromancy (forbidden communication with the dead for divination).
Interestingly, in 1898, the Catholic Church condemned spiritualism but allowed legitimate scientific investigation. This prompted Catholic and Protestant churches to further denounce the practice of spiritualism, while scientific research began to pour into psychic phenomena.
Research into mediumship emerged in the late 1800s. The aim was to explore the legitimacy of these experiences: Could communication with the deceased be scientifically proven? Renowned figures like chemist Sir William Crookes supported the endeavor, leading to significant research funding.
Unfortunately, mediums were repeatedly found to be nothing more than fraudsters. Some of them confessed to using magicians to stage events. This severely damaged spiritualism’s reputation, more so than the Fox sisters’ confession. In America, spiritualism soon moved from mainstream culture to the fringes of society.
Spiritualism fared better overseas. The practice remained strong in England, and countries like Brazil and France (where it was dubbed “spiritism”) incorporated reincarnation into the practice. Perhaps this gave spiritualism some legitimacy since reincarnation has a presence in some major world religions.
But even in America, spiritualism wasn’t truly dead. The modern era would witness a resurgence, even forming the foundation for contemporary ghost hunting and otherworldly exploration.
Stay Tuned for Part Two
Spiritualism, a centuries-old practice built on the idea of contacting the dead, remains surprisingly relevant today. But is there any validity to its claims? Has modern science shed any light on the truth behind these practices, or are they simply a repackaging of age-old illusions used to exploit the downtrodden?
In our next blog post, US Ghost Adventures will continue our exploration into spiritualism’s enduring appeal and how it’s influenced 20th and 21st-century perceptions of ghosts and the unknown.
Sources:
